Trade Reviews

COWHIDE GETS

Jeff Samardzija SF - P DL

Round 13

Round 18

NAPALM GETS

Ross Stripling LAD - P

Round 22

Round 23

Those who aren’t paying attention may have looked at this trade and thought they missed something, and they may have. Stripling has been putting up ace-like numbers this season and the underlying numbers show it’s not a fluke.  That said, we’re talking about a guy who has bounced around between AAA and majors for a while. He went from 28 yo yo-yo player to an ace that warrants 14 rounds of draft picks. It’s a huge boon for Dave and a big risk for Gibby, but one that is worth taking.

====

COWHIDE GETS

Round 20

MONTEZUMAS GETS

Trevor Cahill Oak - P DTD

Round 24

Low level trade for a mid-rotation arm. He’s solid when he’s healthy, but he’s suddenly not healthy again. The nice part about Cahill is he tends to not get blown up too often because of his high groundball tendencies, and when things are going right, he has the ability to put up a 10k complete game shutout. Will he be in the rotation at the end of the season? For four rounds late, it makes sense to try and find out.

===

BROKEBACK GETS           

Harrison Bader StL - OF

Adam Duvall Cin - OF

Round 14

Round 15

ANGRY GETS

Kenta Maeda LAD - P DL

C.J. Cron TB - 1B

Round 17

Round 20

This is a great get by Kyle because he took the DL stint and grabbed a discount on an SP that could be a big contributor. Maeda is worth much more than 8 rounds by himself when healthy, so Watson might have benefited from being more patient. I have little faith in CJ Cron suddenly becoming a top 20 fantasy 1B, but he’s certainly showing he warrants greater usage than he got in LAA. And what the heck happened to Adam Duvall? Anyhow, Kyle for the big win here.

===

ANAL GETS

Sean Doolittle Was - P

Travis Shaw Mil - 3B

Ender Inciarte Atl - OF

DONKEY GETS

Matt Chapman Oak - 3B DTD

Dylan Bundy Bal - P

Jeremy Hellickson Was - P DL

I actually like this one a lot for Jed. Shaw maybe overlooked again as an elite 3B and Inciarte is perpetually underated, but I really like Chapman as a long-term piece and a potential keeper while Bundy has the tantalizing talent to warrant keeper consideration as an SP. Bundy is a strange one because he is absurdly streaky for a pitcher, but it’s hard to argue with a 14.1% SwSTR!!! While I think Shaw is definitely a keeper moving forward, I like the upside of Jed’s return.  Justin meanwhile fills big holes and rids himself of some inconsistent play. This trade was a good one and made even better by the fact that it was strictly players for players – a rarity these days.

===

ONE NUT GETS 

Jake Arrieta Phi - P

Round 21

DONKEY GETS   

Julio Urías LAD - P

Round 12

This is stupid. Ugh. Nine rounds for a top 20 SP? This is one of those cases where people need to tell Jason no and just pose the player to the entire league. I pray to god no value was attached to Urias in this deal…

===

COWHIDE GETS

David Dahl Col - OF DL

Round 13

MONTEZUMAS GETS

Buster Posey SF - C,1B

Round 20

This makes sense, but represents an end to one of the longest running player/manager relationships in H&T history.  I believe only Pierce’s infatuation with David Wright lasted longer. Posey’s days as a keeper are numbered, and one could argue they were numbered a few years ago. The days of Mike Piazza and Ivan Rodriguez are over and the best hitters are getting moved off the position early on. This is Posey’s value at this point, and it makes sense for a team like the Revenge that are in need of OBP help. Good trade.

===

DONKEY GETS

Wil Myers SD - 1B,OF DL

Round 11

Round 14

Round 16

NAPALM GETS

Gerrit Cole Hou - P

Round 18

Round 22

Round 24

That’s 23 rounds and a brittle 1B who shouldn’t be an OF for a leading Cy Young candidates. It’s a pretty good return if you consider Myers a potential keeper again. It’s hard to look past the prolonged injury history, but there’s so few players capabale of 20/20 and much more.  Meanwhile, we’ve just never seen a Gerrit Cole like we’ve seen this Gerrit Cole. Could this be the new reality brought on by Houston’s masterful pitching approach or is it a fluky hot streak from a talented former top prospect? Either way, I like the return for Jed and the bold move by Gibby, who suddenly makes his whole roster look a lot better.